Discussion about this post

User's avatar
David J Dunworth's avatar

Subject: AI in Education: The Case for Closed-System Learning Platforms

While I recognize the potential value of artificial intelligence in education, I remain cautious about the use of open AI platforms as a solution for closing educational gaps at any level.

Educators from middle school through post-graduate programs, including medical schools, technology programs, the sciences, and the liberal arts, are already raising serious concerns about academic integrity. Students are increasingly relying on open platforms such as ChatGPT, Claude, Grok, and others in ways that can blur the line between assistance and substitution.

For that reason, I do not believe open AI platforms are the best answer for structured education, particularly where measurable learning outcomes matter.

However, I strongly support and actively endorse the use of a closed-system AI tutor for the education of both children and adults working within a formal curriculum in rural Africa.

This type of tutor platform does not rely on the open internet and cannot access outside programs, platforms, or applications beyond its gated system. That distinction is critical. It allows AI to function as a true educational support tool rather than an unrestricted shortcut.

For anyone who has worked in the developing world, the challenges are obvious. Reliable Wi-Fi is often limited, unevenly distributed, or expensive. While many people may have access to some type of mobile phone, most devices are 4G, with limited 5G access generally available only to middle-class users. Many of the poorest communities do not have even the most basic digital tools necessary for consistent learning.

Through public-private partnerships, this model can be funded through shared contribution structures, such as 60/40 or 70/30 arrangements. These partnerships can support not only suitable learning devices, but also training, monitoring, and data analytics. This is where the platform becomes especially valuable.

Unlike traditional education models that often measure success by completed lessons, submitted papers, tests, or attendance, a closed-system AI tutor can measure individual learning progress in a more precise and meaningful way. It can track what each learner understands, where they struggle, how quickly they improve, and what support they need next.

That level of clean, individualized data is essential if we are serious about measuring actual learning rather than simply documenting participation.

This closed-system AI tutor is already being used in 17 different applications, ranging from primary education to workforce skills development across the EU and Africa, with active discussions underway in both Central Africa and India.

I would be happy to discuss this platform further with anyone interested in practical, measurable, and scalable solutions for education in rural Africa.

I can be contacted through direct communication on the LinkedIn platform.

David James Dunworth

No posts

Ready for more?