Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Syd Malaxos's avatar

The effort worth keeping is the first attempt. I teach high school chemistry and physics. My students try a problem alone before any tool touches it, then use AI to test and extend what they built. The attempt that comes before the answer is where a student finds out what they actually know. Remove that and you get a correct page and an empty student. I wrote about the mechanism this summer in a preprint called Local Minima, on EdArXiv.

Syd Malaxos, Thinking Labs

Raya Stefanova's avatar

For me, productive difficulty in learning is not simply about preserving effort. It is about making that effort appropriate to the learner’s current abilities — challenging enough to encourage growth, yet achievable enough to support continued progress.

I often explain this principle through running. If my goal is to run 5 kilometres, I would not necessarily start with 5. I might begin with 800 metres. Once I can comfortably manage that distance, I would set myself a new challenge: 1,000 metres. Just 200 metres more. It requires additional effort, but feels realistically achievable. Each accomplishment then becomes the foundation for the next challenge.

The same principle can guide AI-supported learning. Imagine a student who can confidently calculate the perimeter of a rectangle when given its length and width. The next challenge could reverse the problem: the perimeter is 26 cm, and one side is 8 cm. How long is the other side?

AI could help generate appropriately sequenced exercises and provide feedback, while leaving the reasoning to the student. If the learner struggles, instead of revealing the answer, AI might ask: “If two sides are 8 cm each, how much of the perimeter is left for the other two sides?”

In this way, AI does not eliminate meaningful effort. It helps make that effort manageable, purposeful, and supportive of growing independence.

So perhaps the question goes beyond which effort we should preserve: how do we design the right challenge for each individual learner?

1 more comment...

Ready for more?